The Columbus Crew began their 2025 MLS Cup Playoff campaign just 110 miles south in the 513 of Cincinnati, in the second-ever playoff edition of the Hell Is Real Derby, this time in the first round. The night belonged to the Orange and Blue, leaving Columbus stunned in silence. There was promise and mettle from Columbus, but it was Kevin Denkey who got the curtain call with his decisive close-range finish in the 78th minute to put Columbus to bed. 

A tactical first half from both teams may have shown a lack of aggression that most fans would expect from the dubbed “Hell Is Real Derby,” especially given how the Black & Gold finished the regular season. Though seeking to flip their narrative, Nancy and company approached the game with intent. But as the first half unfolded, chances were scarce and the rhythm was halting. Columbus could not find a way past Cincy’s high defensive line, ending the half goalless. 

Within those first 45 minutes, however, the Crew looked to impose their possession-oriented identity, commanding possession and moving the ball through Darlington Nagbe and to the wingers. Still, it lacked the final spark in the final third. Max Arfsten had a shot on target that Roman Celentano saved, but that was the only dangerous opportunity for the MLS originals. 

On the other side, FCC seemed comfortable sitting flat and striking on transitions, keeping Columbus honest without yielding much. At the half, the scoreboard showed goose eggs, which may have reflected the contest’s uncertainty. 

The second half opened similarly — cautious, yet competitive — until the balance shifted in the 78th minute. Kevin Denkey put home a close-range shot that had Crew goalkeeper Patrick Schulte scrambling on his goal line. That goal made 25,000+ erupt in ecstasy, with a little over 200+ falling quiet in the upper deck. 

Following the goal, Columbus pushed with urgency, throwing numbers forward and hoping for an equalizer or some sort of lifeline. Cincinnati closed the ranks, defending its lead with grit in the final 12 minutes, denying any sort of comeback for its rivals. The Crew came close, but as the saying goes — close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades. 

The series now shifts back to Columbus and Lower.com Field, where Columbus will need to put on their best performance if it wants any shot at forcing a Game 3 and advancing. For FCC, the win is more than just progression: it’s pride, validation, and a sort of revenge in a rivalry steeped in meaning. 

What’s next? 

The Columbus Crew hosts FC Cincinnati for Game 2 on Sunday, November 2. Kickoff from Lower.com Field is set for 6:30 p.m. EDT. You can watch the match on MLS Season Pass on Apple TV+.